Pinnacle Picks: Austin’s Sweet Spots for Thanksgiving Pies
Thanksgiving in Austin brings many things—cooler weather (finally), time with loved ones, and of course, the annual scramble to secure the perfect holiday pie. Whether you’re team pumpkin, pecan, apple, or all of the above, Austin’s bakery scene delivers something special for every kind of pie lover.
This year’s Pinnacle Picks rounds up the best spots across Austin and surrounding neighborhoods to help you choose the perfect pie for your holiday table. From French-inspired patisseries to gluten-free gems and heritage-grain artistry, here’s where to order your Thanksgiving showstopper.
1. Abby Jane Bakeshop
16604 Fitzhugh Rd, Dripping Springs, TX
Tucked away in Dripping Springs, Abby Jane Bakeshop is known for its rustic craftsmanship and commitment to heritage grains. Their pies—like apple, pumpkin-cheesecake, and buttermilk grits—deliver a warm, earthy depth of flavor that feels straight out of a farmhouse kitchen.
Holiday pies start at: ~$42
Website: abbyjanebakes.com
2. Bakery Lorraine
11600 Rock Rose Ave, Suite 100, Austin, TX
A French-inspired bakery with a cult following, Bakery Lorraine excels at both precision and comfort. Their Thanksgiving pie lineup includes Dutch apple, pecan, coconut cream, and more—all priced at a budget-friendly $35. It’s hard to beat that combo of quality and value.
Website: bakerylorraine.com
3. Gati
1512 Holly St, Austin, TX
Gati is a haven for those seeking gluten-free and vegan options without sacrificing indulgence. Their holiday menu spans pies, cakes, and beautiful rolled desserts. With prices ranging from $25 to $78, there’s something for every dessert table and dietary need.
Website: gatiatx.com
4. Mañana Coffee
1603 S Congress Ave, Austin, TX
Mañana pairs the cozy charm of a neighborhood café with seasonal pies, ice cream pints, and even fresh whipped cream. It’s the perfect pick-up spot for anyone already strolling South Congress for holiday shopping.
Price range: $35–$40
Website: mananaaustin.com
5. Quack’s 43rd Street Bakery
411 E 43rd St, Austin, TX
A Hyde Park staple, Quack’s brings classic comfort with flavors like pumpkin, cherry, pecan, and key lime. A long-standing neighborhood favorite, their holiday pies offer reliability and charm at approachable prices.
Price range: $30–$35
Website: quacks43rd.com
6. Rockman Coffee + Bakeshop
2400 E Cesar Chavez St, Suite 200, Austin, TX
If you’re looking for something creative and modern, Rockman delivers. Their standout pies—like brown-sugar meringue pumpkin and rosemary-oat apple—bring inventive twists to nostalgic favorites.
Price range: $39–$64
Website: rockmanatx.com
7. Sugar Mama’s Bakeshop
1905 S First St, Austin, TX
This beloved Austin bakery serves homestyle pies with rich flavors like chocolate bourbon pecan, triple-berry buttermilk, and classic Dutch apple. These pies feel like family tradition, just elevated.
Price range: $41–$45
Website: sugarmamasbakeshop.com
8. Swedish Hill Bakery
Multiple Austin locations
Swedish Hill brings a polished bakery experience with seasonal offerings including pumpkin, Dutch apple, and bourbon chocolate pies. At $45 each, these pies taste as refined as they look.
Website: swedishhillaustin.com
9. Tiny Pies
5035 Burnet Rd #100 & 2032 S Lamar Blvd, Austin, TX
Famous for their adorable “not-so-tiny” hand pies, Tiny Pies serves up seasonal flavors like pumpkin chai, apple crumb, and Texas pecan. Whether you choose mini or full-size, they’re always a fun addition to any holiday spread.
Website: tinypies.com
10. Cake & Spoon
Available via farmers markets & local groceries
Cake & Spoon specializes in artisanal small pies (4½") in pecan, banana, pumpkin, and buttermilk—plus larger holiday pies. These handcrafted beauties make perfect gifts or personal indulgences.
Price range: Mini $10 • Large $45–$50
Website: cakeandspoon.com
A Sweet Austin Holiday Awaits
No matter your taste, budget, or dietary needs, Austin’s pie scene has something baked just for you. Thanksgiving is the perfect time to support local bakeries—and treat yourself while you’re at it.
